Posts

Some writers — ones who generally do not depend on their writing to make a living — were always against the suit.

  Some writers — ones who generally do not depend on their writing to make a living — were always against the suit. “Authors of all types fight constantly against the risk of digital obscurity ; for many readers, especially younger readers, if a book is not online, it effectively does not exist to them,” wrote Authors Alliance, which is based in Berkeley, Calif., in its brief in support of the archive. (Mr. Kahle is on the alliance’s 25-member advisory board but played no part in the brief.) A third group of writers have continued and even deepened their opposition to the archive. Douglas Preston, a best-selling thriller writer, pretty much single-handedly led a wing of the writing community in opposition to Amazon and its founder, Jeff Bezos, when the bookseller was embroiled in a dispute with Hachette several years ago. Mr. Preston, a former president of the Authors Guild, now sees Mr. Kahle and his philosophy as more of a threat than Mr. Bezos. “Capitalists may be obnoxious and ...

The emergency library “was as limited as a small city library’s circulation level,” Mr. Kahle insisted. “This was always under control.”

  The emergency library “was as limited as a small city library’s circulation level,” Mr. Kahle insisted. “This was always under control.” But it did not appear that way to the writers who took to Twitter to point out that the books in the library were written by human beings who were often poorly paid and not benefiting from this free information at all. Margaret Owen, an author of popular books for young adults, wrote in a 23-post broadside on Twitter that offering up free books to an audience that could afford to pay for them was, “at this point in history, cutting into our money for hospital and/or funeral bills.” The publishers sued over 127 titles, many by well-known writers, including J.D. Salinger, Sylvia Plath, James Patterson, John Grisham and Malcolm Gladwell. They asked damages of $150,000 a book. Some writers had second thoughts. N.K. Jemisin and Colson Whitehead deleted their critical tweets. Ms. Owen, asked last month by The New York Times if she stood by her tweets,...